The $1 Billion Question: The Hidden Costs of Legacy HR Systems in Government Operations

Secure Workday Support Today

A recent Workday report reveals that outdated human resources (HR) systems cost the U.S. government approximately $1 billion annually. These legacy systems, often reliant on on-premises infrastructure, contribute to inefficiencies, security vulnerabilities, and increased maintenance costs. Modernizing these systems presents an opportunity for significant cost savings and improved operational efficiency

The Hidden Costs of Legacy HR Systems

Maintaining outdated HR systems incurs substantial expenses. According to the U.S. Government Accountability Office, just ten critical federal IT legacy systems cost taxpayers around $337 million annually to operate and maintain. Between 2014 and 2019, maintenance of such systems consumed nearly 80% of the federal government's total IT spending.

These systems often lack integration capabilities, leading to fragmented processes and data silos. Such fragmentation increases the risk of errors, delays in service delivery, and challenges in compliance with evolving regulations.

Real-World Impacts: International Lessons

The consequences of flawed HR system implementations are evident in international examples.

• Canada's Phoenix Pay System: Intended to modernize payroll processing, the Phoenix system led to widespread pay errors affecting nearly 80% of federal employees. By October 2024, the system had cost the government over $3.5 billion, with a backlog of more than 408,000 unresolved pay issues.

• Queensland Health Payroll System: In Australia, a new payroll system for Queensland Health resulted in inaccurate payments for approximately 78,000 staff members. The project, plagued by system defects and inadequate testing, incurred costs exceeding $1.2 billion over eight years.

The Case for Modernization

Transitioning to modern, cloud-based HR systems offers numerous benefits:

• Cost Savings: Workday reports that government organizations have achieved up to 47% savings over ten years when comparing the cost of maintaining existing systems versus upgrading.

• Improved Efficiency: For instance, Clark County, Washington, implemented Workday's solutions and completed payroll 60% faster, cut unapproved spending by 15%, and saved $1.6 million annually.

• Enhanced Compliance and Security: Modern systems offer better compliance tracking and are built with robust security features, reducing the risk of data breaches and regulatory penalties. 

Navigating the Transition: Challenges and Considerations

Navigating the transition from legacy HR systems to modern cloud-based platforms like Workday presents a unique set of challenges for government agencies. While the promise of improved efficiency, data transparency, and user experience is compelling, the path to modernization must be carefully planned to mitigate risks.

• Legacy systems often hold decades of deeply embedded processes and custom configurations that are difficult to unravel.

• Government entities must consider strict compliance requirements, security concerns, budget constraints, and the need for stakeholder alignment across departments. A successful transition requires not only technical readiness but also strategic change management to ensure continuity, user adoption, and long-term value realization.

• Procurement can also be a significant barrier, with lengthy approval processes and strict vendor requirements slowing progress. BGSF helps ease this burden as a certified Workday Deployment Partner and an approved vendor through HGACBuy, a cooperative purchasing program that simplifies procurement for government entities. With BGSF's support, agencies can navigate both the technical and procedural complexities of modernization with greater confidence and speed.

A Smarter Path Forward for Government HR

Outdated HR systems impose significant financial and operational burdens on government agencies. Modernizing these systems is not just a technological upgrade but a strategic investment in efficiency, security, and public trust. By learning from past challenges and prioritizing thoughtful implementation, governments can transform HR operations to better serve both employees and taxpayers.

---

Don’t let outdated HR systems continue to drain your resources and jeopardize compliance. With BGSF as your trusted partner, your agency can confidently move forward with a smarter, more secure, and cost-effective HR solution.

As a certified Workday Deployment Partner and an approved vendor through HGACBuy, BGSF streamlines the path to modernization, cutting through procurement hurdles and aligning technology with your unique operational needs. Contact BGSF today to take the first step toward modern government HR.